Retirement planning is an essential aspect of financial security, both for business owners and their employees. As businesses seek strategies to maximize contributions and ensure their workforce is well-prepared for retirement, they often explore various types of retirement plans. Among the available options, a new comparability plan stands out as an effective method to maximize contributions for highly compensated employees while still maintaining compliance with IRS regulations. But is this type of plan the right fit for your business? Understanding the structure, benefits, and compliance requirements of a new comparability plan can help business owners make an informed decision.
Understanding the New Comparability Plan
A new comparability plan is a type of profit-sharing retirement plan that allows employers to allocate contributions in a way that benefits specific employee groups more than others. Unlike traditional profit-sharing plans, which often distribute contributions uniformly or based on salary percentages, a new comparability plan categorizes employees into different groups and allocates funds accordingly. This plan is particularly useful for business owners and highly compensated employees who wish to maximize their retirement savings while still offering a retirement benefit to other employees.
Under the structure of a new comparability plan, employees are grouped based on various factors such as age, job role, and compensation level. Employers can allocate contributions differently for each group, prioritizing those who are closer to retirement age or those in higher salary brackets. This flexibility makes the plan an attractive option for small and medium-sized businesses with a mix of highly compensated employees and lower-wage earners.
Benefits of a New Comparability Plan
One of the primary advantages of a new comparability plan is its ability to allow business owners and key employees to contribute higher amounts to their retirement accounts compared to traditional profit-sharing plans. Because the IRS allows contributions to be weighted more heavily toward certain groups, the plan enables high earners to save substantially more for retirement.
Another major benefit is the plan’s ability to provide flexibility in contribution allocations. Employers can design their contribution strategy to reward long-term employees or to retain key personnel, making it an excellent tool for employee retention and satisfaction. Additionally, because contributions are discretionary, employers can adjust contributions each year depending on business performance, providing financial adaptability that other types of retirement plans may lack.
A new comparability plan also offers significant tax advantages. Employer contributions are tax-deductible, reducing the company’s taxable income. Employees, in turn, receive tax-deferred growth on their contributions, allowing their retirement savings to accumulate more effectively over time. Given these advantages, it is easy to see why many business owners consider implementing a new comparability plan as part of their broader financial and benefits strategy.
Compliance and Non-Discrimination Testing
While the benefits of a new comparability plan are compelling, businesses must ensure that their plan meets IRS compliance requirements. Specifically, the IRS mandates that these plans pass nondiscrimination testing to ensure they do not disproportionately favor highly compensated employees at the expense of lower-paid workers.
Nondiscrimination testing involves comparing the benefits allocated to different employee groups to confirm that contributions remain equitable. The most common method used for compliance is the “cross-testing” approach, where projected retirement benefits are assessed rather than just current contributions. If a plan fails these tests, adjustments must be made to ensure compliance, which could result in additional employer contributions to lower-paid employees.
Another important compliance factor is maintaining proper documentation and ensuring that employees understand their benefits. Employers should work closely with financial advisors and third-party administrators to navigate the complexities of compliance and to ensure that their retirement plan remains within legal guidelines.
Is a New Comparability Plan Right for Your Business?
Deciding whether a new comparability plan is the right fit for your business requires careful evaluation of your company’s structure, financial goals, and workforce composition. Businesses with a significant gap between highly compensated employees and lower-wage workers stand to benefit the most from this type of plan. If your business is owner-dominated or has a group of key executives who would like to maximize their contributions, a new comparability plan may provide the ideal solution.
However, businesses with a relatively even distribution of salaries across their workforce may not see as much benefit from the plan. Additionally, because the plan requires annual compliance testing and administrative oversight, businesses must be prepared to handle the costs and responsibilities that come with managing the plan. The administrative burden can be mitigated by working with experienced financial advisors who specialize in retirement planning.
If maximizing retirement contributions is a priority and your company has the means to meet compliance requirements, a new comparability plan can be an effective tool for enhancing retirement savings while maintaining financial flexibility. By assessing your business’s unique needs and consulting with retirement planning professionals, you can determine whether this plan aligns with your long-term goals and financial strategy.
Need Pension Consulting & Pension Plans in Phoenix, AZ?
Fiduciary Advisors, Ltd. is a business-to-business associated pension administrator based in Phoenix, Arizona, since 1990. We specialize in designing and planning employee retirement programs, pensions, profit sharing, and are third-party administrators for 401K for small- to medium-size businesses. We conduct enrollment meetings, prepare detailed actuarial calculations, cash-balance plans, and financial consultation for all businesses. Give us a call today for more information!